Navigating complex capacity decisions in social care: Practice Guides and tool (2026)
Introduction
Updated following A Reference by the Attorney General for Northern Ireland [2026] UKSC 16 (AGNI 2026). These resources have been reviewed and updated to reflect the Supreme Court's decision in AGNI (2026). The guides support practitioners to navigate current legal and practice issues relating to mental capacity, liberty, consent, wishes and feelings, and human rights in complex decision-making.
This suite of resources consists of seven specialist guides that address areas of practice in which social care professionals may need to consider mental capacity. Supporting practice in complex areas, whether working with people who use alcohol or drugs, have Prader-Willi syndrome, or are experiencing domestic abuse, self-neglect or mental health difficulties, the guides have been updated to reflect developments in law and practice, including the Supreme Court's decision in AGNI.
Each guide builds on the guidance set out in Mental Capacity Act (MCA) 2005 decision-making – care, support and treatment: Practice Tool, also published by Research in Practice.
The guides support readers with key learning in each specific area, presenting relevant legislation, case law, MCA guidance, practice considerations and reflective prompts. They include consideration of the implications of AGNI for social care practice, including issues relating to liberty, consent, wishes and feelings, and rights-based decision-making. Particular attention is given to areas where practitioners must navigate complex questions about liberty, restrictions, consent, wishes and feelings, and human rights following AGNI.
The specialist guides focus on:
Supporting people who use alcohol or drugs.
Supporting people who self-neglect.
Supporting people experiencing domestic abuse.
Supporting people with Prader-Willi syndrome.
Informal admissions to hospital for mental health care.
Community treatment orders.
Restrictive and controlling interventions.
Understanding the implications of AGNI for complex capacity and liberty decisions in social care.
In addition to the guides, there is a decisional balance tool:
Making best interests decisions around mental health hospital admissions and accommodation.
Professional Standards
CQC - Safe | Effective | Caring | Responsive
PCF - Values and ethics | Rights, justice and economic wellbeing | Knowledge | Critical reflection and analysis | Intervention and skills
RCOT - Service users | Identify needs | Support development
This publication is a premium resource
Access the full publication with a one-off purchase or enjoy the benefits of membership.
This November 2026 edition is the latest update to the original resource, first published in October 2025. It has been revised to reflect the UK Supreme Court judgment of 2 June 2026.
With thanks to Emma Hill for her contribution to this update.